Check out this new paper in Thinking and Reasoning, based on studies conducted as part of Fernando Rodriguez’s dissertation
Rodriguez, F., Rhodes, R., Miller, K., & Shah, P. (in press). Examining the influence of anecdotal stories and the interplay of individual differences on reasoning. Thinking and Reasoning. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13546783.2016.1139506?journalCode=ptar20
And, in as similar vein:
Rodriguez, F., Ng, A., & Shah, P. (in press). Do college students notice errors in evidence when evaluating research findings? Journal of Excellence in College Teaching.