Op-ed: Potential Beneficiaries and Losers in a Global Tariff War 

Written by Meiting Xu

Tariffs are well-liked by many around the world, but nobody loves them more than President Donald Trump, who has kept tariffs at the center of his foreign policy. In less than a month since he took office, he had threatened to impose tariffs on Canada, Mexico, China, and Colombia. Colombia yielded on deportation flights from the U.S. to avert a trade war at the last minute, and both Canada and Mexico created a breathing space for themselves when they promised to boost border enforcement in exchange for delayed tariffs. However, China was hit with a 10% tariff which it later retaliated against with its own tariffs on American goods. 

Tariffs are nothing new to the world. Countries frequently used them in the name of protectionism. However, the end of WWII signaled a more globalized economy and interconnected trade practices such that tariffs largely fell out of favor and gave way to more integrated economic practices. Lately, tariffs have returned to the spotlight primarily because protectionism is rising in many industrialized countries. Although tariffs inflict acute pain on consumers when first imposed, I think they can benefit unskilled workers in sectors that experience heavy import competition. Moreover, countries generally favor terms of trade because it allows them to gain an advantage over their trading partners, meaning that they have higher purchasing power to buy more imports with the same quantity of exports. Yet, the power of tariffs peaks only if no retaliatory actions are taken by a country’s trading partner, which is impossible in the real world. Should the trading partner also raise its import tariffs, then the terms of trade effect will likely be insignificant, and importers might offset the higher prices of goods by charging consumers more. 

In an ideal world, the optimal tariff stands close to zero because we want market efficiency, allowing markets to run freely based on a country’s comparative advantage. Nevertheless, the economy is often significantly tied to politics, foreign policies, and national security, which prevents the markets from acting only as pure markets. In other words, markets serve as a signal of the broader political climate and complement foreign policy interests at times. Therefore, tariffs are now more commonly used as a trade policy tool and are primarily paid by U.S. consumers rather than foreign sellers (SLS, 2024). They can potentially protect the domestic industries for a while but are often followed by retaliatory measures from other countries. This means that the promised benefits of increased manufacturing and significant revenue generation are questionable (SLS, 2024). 

Additionally, I believe that tariffs hit different sectors unevenly, even with compensation programs, which might have inconsistent distributions and efforts. When the modern supply chains are disrupted by old-style protectionist trade policies, U.S. manufacturers have to reduce exports that depend on imported immediate goods (Edelberg & Obstfeld, 2024). This is because supply chains are challenging to reconfigure, and reconfiguration to offset higher costs might backfire (Edelberg & Obstfeld, 2024). Some sectors, such as energy, auto, aerospace manufacturing, metals, and agriculture commodities, stand at the forefront of retaliatory efforts from foreign entities, exposing them to higher input prices, lowered production rates, and falling employment rates (Reid, 2025). Likewise, tariffs tend to squeeze small and medium-sized companies more than large corporations, resulting in sticker shock for consumers. Small and medium-sized companies cannot absorb as many tariffs as large corporations, so they are forced to pass on the costs early to consumers before breaking even. Some importers will also appeal for exemptions from tariffs, but only those who are politically favored by the government are likely to succeed (Edelberg & Obstfeld, 2024). Large corporations tend to ingratiate themselves with the government through obsequious behavior because they have the means and skills to navigate the political landscape. 

On the other hand, I argue that tariffs on imports could stimulate demand for domestic goods, allowing some products to remain highly competitive against higher-priced imports. At the same time, domestic companies might benefit from economies of scale, which would lower production costs and keep prices low for consumers. Companies are also likely to return to their domestic countries since the cost of sourcing imported goods from foreign countries rises. They will turn to more economical means, such as sourcing the materials domestically and producing the goods domestically. Tariff threats might also morph into tariff wars, sharply escalating trade tensions between countries and contributing to trade uncertainties. In the short run, workers in the exporting sector lose when labor demands shift towards the import-competing sector. Still in the long term, unskilled workers benefit more when labor demands shift towards the unskilled-intensive import-competing sector (Lechthaler & Mileva, 2018). 

After all, tariffs have increasingly caused countries to disengage from multilateral trade frameworks. Consumers and producers have dramatically different preferences for optimal tariffs. Notwithstanding what leaders might say about tariffs, they should be employed cautiously.  

References:

Edelberg, W. & Obstfeld, M. (2024, October 7). Tariffs on all imports would create chaos for business. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/tariffs-on-all-imports-would-create-chaos-for-business/ 

Large cargo port. (2024, September 2). Wikimedia Commons. https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Large_cargo_port_(Unsplash).jpg&oldid=918321371 

Lechthaler, W. & Mileva, Mariya. (2018). Who Benefits from Trade Wars? Intereconomics Review of European Economic Policy, 53 (1), 22-26. https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2018/number/1/article/who-benefits-from-trade-wars.html 

Reid, M. (2025, February 5). What tariffs could mean for the U.S. economy. RBC Thought Leadership. https://thoughtleadership.rbc.com/quick-reid-what-tariffs-could-mean-for-the-u-s-economy/ 

Tariffs, Trade Wars, and Policy Shifts under Trump: A Tutorial on the Global Economy and Trade. (2024, December 19). SLS Stanford Legal. https://law.stanford.edu/stanford-legal-podcast/tariffs-trade-wars-and-policy-shifts-under-trump-a-tutorial-on-the-global-economy-and-trade/